Publicación:
Deliberative, Republican, and Egalitarian Institutional Alternatives for Popular Constitutionalism

dc.contributor.authorBello Hutt, Donaldspa
dc.date.accessioned2020-12-07 14:09:25
dc.date.accessioned2022-09-09T21:05:57Z
dc.date.available2020-12-07 14:09:25
dc.date.available2022-09-09T21:05:57Z
dc.date.issued2020-12-07
dc.description.abstractEste artículo examina y propone alternativas institucionales para el constitucionalismo popular. La propuesta es una combinación progresiva de instituciones que buscan dotar a la ciudadanía con el poder final para determinar qué significa una constitución, contribuyendo a asegurar su libertad republicana, implementando mecanismos de deliberación, al tiempo que es respetuoso de una forma particular de comprender la igualdad política. El artículo comienza con una descripción del constitucionalismo popular y de los principios que considero que deberían fundamentar la teoría. Luego, procede a examinar críticamente diversas propuestas institucionales presentes en la literatura. Después de mostrar las áreas en las que dichas propuestas se quedan cortas en el esfuerzo de encarnar los principios aquí defendidos, el artículo aboga por la implementación de cuatro mecanismos que, según sostendré, sí se acercan más a dichos objetivos.spa
dc.description.abstractThis article examines and proposes institutional instantiations for popular constitutionalism. The proposal is a progressive combination of institutions aiming at giving the citizenry the opportunity to determine what a constitution means, contributing to securing their liberty in a republican sense, implementing mechanisms of deliberation, and being respectful to a particular understanding of political equality. It first describes popular constitutionalism and the principles I believe should ground it. It then moves on to scrutinize sundry institutional alternatives available in the literature. After showing the areas where those proposals fall short of instantiating the principles here championed, the article argues for the implementation of four mechanisms that, I argue, do incarnate those principles.eng
dc.format.mimetypeapplication/pdfspa
dc.format.mimetypeapplication/xmlspa
dc.format.mimetypetext/htmlspa
dc.identifier.doi10.18601/01229893.n48.07
dc.identifier.eissn2346-2051
dc.identifier.issn0122-9893
dc.identifier.urihttps://bdigital.uexternado.edu.co/handle/001/11244
dc.identifier.urlhttps://doi.org/10.18601/01229893.n48.07
dc.language.isospaspa
dc.publisherDepartamento de Derecho Constitucionalspa
dc.relation.bitstreamhttps://revistas.uexternado.edu.co/index.php/derest/article/download/6960/9525
dc.relation.bitstreamhttps://revistas.uexternado.edu.co/index.php/derest/article/download/6960/9795
dc.relation.bitstreamhttps://revistas.uexternado.edu.co/index.php/derest/article/download/6960/9864
dc.relation.citationeditionNúm. 48 , Año 2021 : Enero-Abrilspa
dc.relation.citationendpage214
dc.relation.citationissue48spa
dc.relation.citationstartpage183
dc.relation.ispartofjournalRevista Derecho del Estadospa
dc.relation.referencesAckerman, Bruce y James S. Fishk in. Deliberation Day, yup, New Haven & London, 2004.spa
dc.relation.referencesAlexy, Robert. Constitutional Rights, Balancing and Rationality. Ratio Juris, 16: 2, 2003a: 131-140.spa
dc.relation.referencesAlexy, Robert. On Balancing and Subsumption. A Structural Comparison. Ratio Juris 16: 4, 2003b: 433-449.spa
dc.relation.referencesAlterio, Ana Micaela & Niembro, Roberto. Constitucionalismo popular en Latinoamérica, México DF: Porrúa, 2013.spa
dc.relation.referencesAtria, Fernando. Revisión judicial: el síndrome de la víctima insatisfecha. Estudios Públicos, 2000: 347-402.spa
dc.relation.referencesBächtiger, André, Maija Setäla & Gröndlund. Towards a New Era of Deliberative Mini-Publics. In Grönlund, Kimmo, André Bächtiger & Setälä, Maija (eds.). Deliberative Mini-Publics. Involving Citizens in the Democratic Process, ecpr Press, Colchester, 2014: 225-245.spa
dc.relation.referencesBarak, Aharon. Proportionality: Constitutional Rights and Their Limitations, cup, Cambridge, 2012.spa
dc.relation.referencesBeatty, David M. The Ultimate Rule of Law. OUP, Oxford, 2005.spa
dc.relation.referencesBeaumont, Elizabeth. The Civic Constitution: Civic Visions and Struggles in the Path Toward Constitutional Democracy, OUP, Oxford, 2014.spa
dc.relation.referencesBellamy, Richard. Political Constitutionalism. A Republican Defence of the Constitutionality of Democracy, cup, Cambridge, 2007.spa
dc.relation.referencesBello, Donald E. Against Judicial Supremacy in Constitutional Interpretation 31 (2017a): 7-28.spa
dc.relation.referencesBello, Donald E. Deliberation and Courts: The Role of the Judiciary in a Deliberative System, Theoria: A Journal of Social and Political Theory 152 (64), 2017b: 77-103spa
dc.relation.referencesBello, Donald E. Republicanism, Deliberative Democracy, and Equality of Access and Deliberation, Theoria (Wiley) 84 (1), 2018: 83-111.spa
dc.relation.referencesBohman, James. Epistemic Value and Deliberative Democracy. The Good Society 18 (2) (2009): 28-34.spa
dc.relation.referencesBohman, James. Public Deliberation. Pluralism, Complexity, and Democracy. The mit Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts; London, 1996.spa
dc.relation.referencesBohman, James. Representation in the deliberative system. In John Parkinson and Jane Mansbridge (eds.), Deliberative Systems. Deliberative Democracy at the Large Scale, cup, Cambridge, 2012: 72-94.spa
dc.relation.referencesBohman, James. Survey Article: The Coming of Age of Deliberative Democracy. The Journal of Political Philosophy 6 (4) (1998): 400-425.spa
dc.relation.referencesBonneau, Chris W. & Gann Hall, Melinda. In Defense of Judicial Elections. Routledge, New York, 2009.spa
dc.relation.referencesBoswell, John, Carolyn M. Hendriks & Selen A. Ercan. Message received? Examining transmission in Deliberative Systems. Critical Policy Studies 10 (3), 2016: 263-283.spa
dc.relation.referencesButton, Mark & David Michael Ryfe. What can we Learn from the Practice of Deliberative Democracy?. In John Gastil & Petter Levine (eds.). The Deliberative Democracy Handbook. Strategies for Effective Civic Engagement in the 21st Century, Jossey-Bass, San Francisco: 2005: 20-33.spa
dc.relation.referencesCalvert, Aubin & Mark E. Warren. Deliberative Democracy and Framing Effects: Why Frames are a Problem and How Deiberative MIni-Publics MIight Overcome Them. In Grönlund, Kimmo, André Bächtiger & Setälä, Maija (eds.). Deliberative Mini-Publics. Involving Citizens in the Democratic Process, ecpr Press, Colchester, 2014: 203-223.spa
dc.relation.referencesChambers, Simone. Deliberation and Mass Democracy. In John Parkinson & Jane Mansbridge (eds.), Deliberative Systems. Deliberative Democracy at the Large Scale, cup, Cambridge, 2012: 53-71.spa
dc.relation.referencesChambers, Simone. Deliberative Democratic Theory. Annual Review of Political Science 6, 2003: 307-326.spa
dc.relation.referencesCohen, Joshua. Deliberation and Democratic Legitimacy. In James Bohman & William Rehg (eds.). Deliberative Democracy, The mit Press, Cambridge, Massachusets & London.1998, 67-92.spa
dc.relation.referencesCouso, Javier A. The Politics of Judicial Review in Chile in the Era of Domestic Transition, 1990-2002. In Siri Gloppen, Roberto Gargarella & Elin Skaar (eds.). Democratization and the Judiciary. The Accoountability Function of Courts in New Democracies, Frank Cass, New York, 2005, 70-91.spa
dc.relation.referencesDahl, Robert. Democracy and its Critics. yup, New Haven & London, 1989.spa
dc.relation.referencesDelli Carpini, Michael X., Fay Lomax Cook & R. Lawrence Jakobs . Public Deliberations, Discursive Participation and Citizen Engagement: A Review of the Empirical Literature. Annual Review of Political Science 7 (1), 2004: 315-344.spa
dc.relation.referencesDonnelly, Tom. Making Popular Constitutionalism Work. Wisconsin Law Review 2012: 159-194.spa
dc.relation.referencesElster, Jon. Introduction. In Jon Elster, (ed.) Deliberative Democracy. CUP, Cambridge, 1998, 1-18.spa
dc.relation.referencesFishk in, James S. The Voice of the People. Public Opinion and Democracy. YUP, New Haven, 1997.spa
dc.relation.referencesFishk in, James S. & Robert C. Luskin. The Quest for Deliberative Democracy. In Michael Saward (ed.). Democratic Innovation: Deliberation, Representation and Association Routledge, London, 2000, 17-28.spa
dc.relation.referencesFishk in, James & Cynthia Farrar. Deliberative Polling. From Experiment to Community Resource. In John Gastil & Peter Levine (eds.). The Deliberative Democracy Handbook.spa
dc.relation.referencesStrategies for Effective Civic Engagement in the 21st Century, Jossey - Bass, San Francisco, 2005, 68-79.spa
dc.relation.referencesFriedman, Barry. Mediated Popular Constitutionalism. Michigan Law Review 101 (8), 2003: 2596-2636.spa
dc.relation.referencesFung, Archon. Survey Article: Recipes for Public Spheres: Eight Institutional Design Choices and Their Consequences. The Journal of Political Philosophy 11 (3), 203: 338-367.spa
dc.relation.referencesGardbaum, Stephen. Reassessing the new Commonwealth model of constitutionalism. Icon 8, 2010: 167-206.spa
dc.relation.referencesGardbaum, Stephen. The New Commonwealth Model of Constitutionalism. Theory and Practice. cup, Cambridge, 2013.spa
dc.relation.referencesGargarella, Roberto. El nuevo constitutionalismo dialógico, frente al sistema de pesos y contrapesos. Revista Argentina de Teoría Jurídica 14 (2), 2013: 356-362.spa
dc.relation.referencesGargarella, Roberto. La justicia frente al gobierno. Sobre el carácter contramayoritario del poder judicial. Ariel, Barcelona, 1996.spa
dc.relation.referencesGoodin, Robert E. & John S. Dryzek. Deliberative Impacts: The Macro-Political Uptake of Mini-Publics. Politics & Society 34 2, 2006: 219-244.spa
dc.relation.referencesGosh, Eric. Deliberative Democracy and the Countermajoritarian Difficulty: Considering Constitutional Juries. ojls 30 (2), 2010: 327-359.spa
dc.relation.referencesGutmann, Amy & Dennis Thompson. Democracy and Disagreement. The Belknap Press of HUP, Cambridge, Massachusetts & London ,1996.spa
dc.relation.referencesHabermas, Jürgen. Between Facts and Norms: Contributions to a Discourse Theory of Law and Democracy. The mit Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1996.spa
dc.relation.referencesHabermas, Jürgen. Justification and Application. Remarks on Discourse Ethics. The mit Press, Massachussets & London, 1993.spa
dc.relation.referencesHanssen, Andrew F. The Political Economy of Judicial Selection: Theory and Evidence. Kansas Journal of Law & Public Policy 9 (3), 1999: 413-424.spa
dc.relation.referencesHendriks, Carolyn M. Consensus Conferences and Planning Cells. Lay Citizen Deliberations. In John Gastil & Peter Levine (eds.). The Deliberative Democracy Handbook. Strategies for Effective Civic Engagement in the 21st Century. Jossey Bass, San Francisco, 2005: 80-110spa
dc.relation.referencesHiebert L., Janet. Parliamentary Bills of Rights: An Alternative Model?. The Modern Law Review 69 (1), 2006: 7-28.spa
dc.relation.referencesHogg , Peter W. & Allison A. Bushell. El Diálogo de la Carta Entre Tribunales y las Legislaturas. Revista Argentina de Teoría Juridica 14 (2), (2013).spa
dc.relation.referencesKant, Immanuel. Critique of Pure Reason. Hacket Publishing, Indianapolis & Cambridge, 1996.spa
dc.relation.referencesKant, Immanuel. Toward Perpetual Peace. In Pauline Kleingeld ed.). Toward Perpetual Peace and Other Writings on Politics, Peace, and History. yup, New Haven & London 2006, 67-109.spa
dc.relation.referencesKnowles, Helen J. & Julianne A. Toia. Defining ‘Popular Constitutionalism: The Kramer versus Kramer Problem. Southern University Law Review 42 (1), 2014: 31-59.spa
dc.relation.referencesKramer, Larry. “The Interest of the Man”: James Madison, Popular Constitutionalism, and the Theory of Deliberative Democracy.” Valparaiso Law Review 41 (2), 2007: 697-754.spa
dc.relation.referencesKramer, Larry. The People Themselves. Popular Constitutionalism and Judicial Review. OUP, Oxford, 2004a.spa
dc.relation.referencesLarmore, Charles. A Critique of Philip Pettit’s Republicanism. Philosophical Issues, 2001: 229-243.spa
dc.relation.referencesLorenzetti, Ricardo. Las Audiencias Públicas y la Corte Suprema. Revista Argentina de Teoría Política 14 (2), 2013.spa
dc.relation.referencesLovett, Frank. “Republicanism.” Standford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. 10 11 2014, http://plato.stanford.edu/cgi-in/encyclopedia/archinfo.cgi?entry=republicanism.spa
dc.relation.referencesMadison, James. Who Are the Best Keepers of the People’s Liberties?. In Ralph Ketcham (ed.), Selected Writings of James Madison. Hackett Publishing Company, Indianapolis/Cambridge, 2006, 227-229.spa
dc.relation.referencesManin, Bernard. On Legitimacy and Political Deliberation. Political Theory 15 (3), 1987: 338-368.spa
dc.relation.referencesManin, Bernard. The Principles of Representative Government. cup, Cambridge, 1997.spa
dc.relation.referencesMansbridge, Jane et al. A systemic approach to deliberative democracy. In John Parkinson & Jane Mansbridge (eds.). Deliberative systems: deliberative democracy at the large scale. Theories of Institutional Design, cup, Cambridge, 2012, 1-26.spa
dc.relation.referencesMansbridge, Jane et al. The Place of Self-Interest and the Role of Power in Deliberative Democracy. The Journal of Political Philosophy 18 (1), 2010: 64-100.spa
dc.relation.referencesMarcilla, Gema. Balancing as a Guide to Legislative Reasoning. Legisprudence 4 (1), 2010: 93-104.spa
dc.relation.referencesMarmor, Andrei. The Language of Law. oup, Oxford, 2014.spa
dc.relation.referencesMartí, José Luis. La república deliberativa. Marcial Pons, Madrid, 2006.spa
dc.relation.referencesMcCormick, John. Machiavellian Democracy. cup, Cambridge, 2011.spa
dc.relation.referencesMiller, David. Deliberative Democracy and Social Choice. Political Studies 40 (1), 1992: 54-67.spa
dc.relation.referencesOliver-Lalana, Daniel. ¿Le importa a alguien que los legisladores razonen? Sobre el análisis y el control del debate parlamentario de las leyes. Revista da Faculdade de Direito da Universidade de Lisboa 57 (2), 2016: 5-37.spa
dc.relation.referencesOliver-Lalana, Daniel. Foreword: Towards a Theory of Legislative Argument. Legisprudence 4 (1), 2010: 3-12.spa
dc.relation.referencesOvejero Lucas, Félix. La libertad inhóspita. Modelos humanos y democracia liberal. Paidós, Barcelona, 2002.spa
dc.relation.referencesParkinson, John. Deliberating in the Real World. oup, Oxford, 2006.spa
dc.relation.referencesPettit, Philip. On the People’s Terms: A reply to five critiques. Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy (crispp) 18 (6), 2015: 687-696.spa
dc.relation.referencesPettit, Philip. On the People’s Terms. A Republican Theory and Model of Democracy. cup, Cambridge, 2012.spa
dc.relation.referencesPettit, Philip. Republicanism. A Theory of Freedom and Government. Clarendon Press, Oxford 1997.spa
dc.relation.referencesPintore, Anna. Democrazia e diritti. Sette studi analitici. Edizioni ets, Pisa, 2010.spa
dc.relation.referencesPitkin, Hanna. The Concept of Representation. University of California Press, Berkeley, 1967.spa
dc.relation.referencesPost, Robert & Reva Siegel. Democratic Constitutionalism. In Jack Balkin & Reva Siegel (eds.). The Constitution in 2020. oup, Oxford, 2009, 25-34.spa
dc.relation.referencesPozen, David. Judicial Elections as Popular Constitutionalism. Columbia Law Review 110, 2010 2047-2134.spa
dc.relation.referencesRehg , William. Translator’s Introduction. In Jürgen Habermas, Between Facts and Norms. Contributions to a Discourse Theory of Law and Democracy, The mit Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1996, ix-xliiispa
dc.relation.referencesRodríguez Garavito, César. El Activismo Dialógico y el Impacto de los Fallos Sobre Derechos Sociales. Revista Argentina de Teoría Jurídica 14 (2), 2013: 211-244.spa
dc.relation.referencesRyan, Matthew & Graham Smith. “Defining Mini-publics”. In Kimmo Grönlund, André Bächtiger & Maija Setälä (eds.). Deliberative mini-publics. Involving citizens in the democratic process, ecpr Press, Colchester, 2014, 9-26spa
dc.relation.referencesSanders, Lynn. Poll Envy: An Assessment of Deliberative Polling. The Good Society 9, (1), 1999: 9-14.spa
dc.relation.referencesSchäfer, Andreas. Deliberation in representative institutions: an analytical framework for a systemic approach. Australian Journal of Political Science, 2017: 1-17.spa
dc.relation.referencesSchk ade, David, Cass R. Sunstein & Reid Hastie. When Deliberation Produces Extremism. Critical Review 2010: 227-252.spa
dc.relation.referencesSchlink, Bernhard. Proportionality in Constitutional Law: Why everywhere but here. Duke Journal of Comparative & International Law 22 (2012): 291-302.spa
dc.relation.referencesSchmidt, Christopher. The Tea Party and the Constitution. 2011. The Tea Party and the Constitution. Available at: http://scholarship.kentlaw.iit.edu/fac_schol/546spa
dc.relation.referencesSchwartzberg, Melissa. Should Progressive Constitutionalism Embrace Popular Constitutionalism?, Ohio State Law Journal 72 (6), 2011, 1295-1316.spa
dc.relation.referencesSebastián, Linares. Justicia dialógica interinstitucional: de lege ferenda y de lege lata. Revista Argentina de Teoría Jurídica 14 (2), 2013.spa
dc.relation.referencesSieckmann, Jan. Legislative Argumentation and Democratic Legitimation. Legisprudence 4 (1), 2010: 69-91.spa
dc.relation.referencesSkinner, Quentin. A Third Concept of Liberty. Proceedings of the British Academy, 2002: 237-268.spa
dc.relation.referencesSkinner, Quentin. Hobbes and Republican Liberty. cup, Cambridge, 2008.spa
dc.relation.referencesSkinner, Quentin. Liberty before Liberalism. cup, Cambridge, 1998.spa
dc.relation.referencesSunstein, Cass. The Law of Group Polarization. The Journal of Political Philosophy 10 (2), 2002: 175-195.spa
dc.relation.referencesSydney, Algernon. Discourses Concerning Government. Edited by Thomas G. West, Liberty Fund, Indianapolis, 1698.spa
dc.relation.referencesTschentscher, Axel, André Bächtiger, Jürg Steiner & Marco Steenbergen. Deliberation in Parliaments. Research Objectives and Prelminary Results of the Bern Center for Interdisciplinary Deliberation Studies (bids). Legisprudence 4 (1), 2010: 13-34.spa
dc.relation.referencesTushnet, Mark. Non-Judicial Review. Harvard Journal on Legislation 40 (2003): 453- 92.spa
dc.relation.referencesTushnet, Mark. Taking the Constitution Away from the Courts. pup, Princeton, 1999.spa
dc.relation.referencesUrbinati, Nadia. Representation as Advocacy. Political Theory 28 (6), 2000: 758-786.spa
dc.relation.referencesWaldron, Jeremy. Political Political Theory. hup, Cambridge, Massachusetts: 2016.spa
dc.relation.referencesWaldron, Jeremy. Representative Lawmaking. Boston University Law Review 89 (2009): 335-355.spa
dc.relation.referencesWaldron, Jeremy. The Core of the Case Against Judicial Review. The Yale Law Journal, 115 (2006): 1346-1406.spa
dc.relation.referencesWaldron, Jeremy. The Dignity of Legislation. cup, Cambridge, 1999.spa
dc.relation.referencesWintgens, Luc J. Legisprudence as a New Theory of Legislation. Ratio Juris 19 (1), 2006: 1-25.spa
dc.relation.referencesZietlow, Rebecca E. Popular Originalism? The Tea Party Movement and Constitutional Theory. Florida Law Review 64 (2), 2012: 483-512.spa
dc.rightsDonald Bello Hutt - 2020spa
dc.rights.accessrightsinfo:eu-repo/semantics/openAccessspa
dc.rights.coarhttp://purl.org/coar/access_right/c_abf2spa
dc.rights.urihttps://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/spa
dc.sourcehttps://revistas.uexternado.edu.co/index.php/derest/article/view/6960spa
dc.subjectPopular constitutionalism;eng
dc.subjectrepublicanisms;eng
dc.subjectinstitutional design;eng
dc.subjectdeliberation;eng
dc.subjectpolitical equality.eng
dc.subjectConstitucionalismo popular;spa
dc.subjectrepublicanismo;spa
dc.subjectdiseño institucional;spa
dc.subjectdeliberación;spa
dc.subjectequidad políticaspa
dc.titleDeliberative, Republican, and Egalitarian Institutional Alternatives for Popular Constitutionalismspa
dc.title.translatedDeliberative, Republican, and Egalitarian Institutional Alternatives for Popular Constitutionalismeng
dc.typeArtículo de revistaspa
dc.type.coarhttp://purl.org/coar/resource_type/c_6501spa
dc.type.coarhttp://purl.org/coar/resource_type/c_6501spa
dc.type.coarversionhttp://purl.org/coar/version/c_970fb48d4fbd8a85spa
dc.type.contentTextspa
dc.type.driverinfo:eu-repo/semantics/articlespa
dc.type.localJournal articleeng
dc.type.redcolhttp://purl.org/redcol/resource_type/ARTREFspa
dc.type.versioninfo:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersionspa
dspace.entity.typePublication
Archivos